Horizon Scan Ep. 44 |⚡️Should UK Police Be Armed | ⚡️Violent Crime Stats | ⚡️Institutions Failing

Horizon Scan

In this episode, Gaz and Hugh discuss various topics, including the sound quality of the podcast, the need for police to be properly supported, and their breakfast choices. They also mention the possibility of disagreements between them. The conversation explores the question of whether the police should be armed. There are two sides to this issue: those who believe that arming the police is necessary for their safety and effectiveness, and those who believe that it can lead to misuse of weapons and unnecessary violence. The discussion also touches on the reputation of police officers in America and the need for reform in the use of firearms. The legal complexities and the challenges of handling armed incidents are highlighted as well. The conversation discusses the use of tasers and arming police officers. It highlights the need for proper training and the potential consequences of arming officers without adequate preparation. The lack of training can lead to a degradation in support for the police and an increase in incidents where people are killed. The conversation also explores the behavior of police officers in high-pressure conflict situations and the importance of their training in handling such scenarios. The conversation explores the use of tasers by police officers and the potential consequences. It highlights the importance of proper training and assessment of threat levels in high-stress situations. The defaulting to using a weapon can lead to excessive violence and potential harm. The different perspectives and backgrounds of individuals shape their understanding of confrontations. The conversation explores the need for training and experiences in the police force, as well as the challenges faced by officers. It highlights the importance of selecting the right individuals for the job and the impact of recruitment on the effectiveness of the police force. The conversation also touches on the need for police officers to be able to handle conflict and aggression, and the responsibility they have in upholding the law. The discussion emphasizes the need for reform and retraining in modern policing. The conversation explores the concept of courageous restraint in military operations and the challenges of implementing it. It discusses the need for a change in mindset and methodology when faced with high-stress situations. The conversation also touches on the importance of quick thinking and the limitations of using excessive force. Overall, it emphasizes the need for a balanced approach to conflict resolution. The conversation explores the increase in violent crime and armed attacks in the UK, specifically focusing on knife attacks. It is suggested that there has been a sustained increase in armed attacks, including bullets, bombs, and mortars. The discussion also touches on the need to consider increasing the number of armed officers in the police force. However, it is noted that the increase in violent crime is not limited to London but is a UK-wide issue. The conversation explores the topic of violent crime and its impact on society. The hosts discuss the lack of a defined definition for violent crime and how this may give a false representation of the actual figures. They also touch on the decision paralysis and fear of getting involved in addressing violent crime. The conversation references the Office for National Statistics and the Crime Survey for England and Wales to provide an overview of the overall trend in violent crime. There has been a general downward trend in violent crime since its peak in 1995. The number of incidents of violent crime remains broadly similar to pre-pandemic levels. However, the statistics may be influenced by changes in how violent crime is defined and reported. The decrease in violent crime may also be due to changes in government policies and coalitions. Overall, the visibility of violent crime has increased due to the information age. The conversation discusses the rise in violence and crime rates, particularly involving weapons. The speakers express concern about the increase in violent incidents and the impact it has on society. They highlight the need for a deeper understanding of the experiences of the police and the people on the ground. The conversation also touches on the availability of firearms and the involvement of criminals in weapon-related crimes. The conversation explores the topic of firearms and knife offenses recorded by the police. It discusses the increase in the percentage of these offenses between 2011 and 2020. The use of tasers by police officers is also mentioned, with the understanding that not all officers carry them. The conversation highlights the challenges and decisions faced by police officers in potentially dangerous situations. The responsibility of law enforcement is to be physically fit and able to protect and defend the public. It is important for officers to have the necessary training and physical capabilities to handle dangerous situations. The public relies on law enforcement to keep them safe, and officers should be prepared to handle any threats or attacks. Being physically fit and skilled in self-defense techniques can give officers an advantage in dangerous situations. The conversation explores the need for individuals to rethink their job and aspire to be the best in their field. It discusses how the military and police force have high expectations for their members and recognize the importance of motivation and attitude. The conversation also touches on the minimum entry requirements for these professions and the impact of training and upskilling on their capabilities. It concludes by highlighting the importance of being a professional and recognizing the need for continuous improvement. The conversation revolves around the challenges and limitations of being a police officer and the need for improvement in the profession. The main themes include the difficulty of the job, the need for better training and fitness standards, and the importance of understanding and manipulating the law. The conversation also touches on the idea of an ideal world and the compromises that need to be made in reality. The conversation explores the idea of overqualification and the impact of requiring degrees for certain jobs. It discusses the potential drawbacks of this approach, including the possibility of people being overqualified for positions that don't require a degree. The conversation also touches on the role of universities in brainwashing and the need for a pushback against the emphasis on degrees. Overall, the conversation highlights the need for a balance between education and practical skills. The conversation explores the idea of arming police officers and the potential consequences of doing so. Gaz suggests that everyone should have a taser and officers should have the option to carry firearms. However, Hugh disagrees and believes that arming police officers would create more problems than it would solve. They discuss the need for rigorous training and the potential for misuse of weapons. Gaz emphasizes the importance of giving officers the option to carry, while Hugh argues for specialized units instead. The conversation discusses the idea of allowing everyone to carry weapons and the importance of training and familiarity with firearms. It also explores the potential drawbacks of widespread carrying and the need for competency. The main takeaway is that while offering the option to carry may motivate some individuals, it may also lead to issues if not properly regulated. The conversation revolves around the disagreement between Hugh and Gaz regarding the method of incentivizing employees. Gaz believes that employees should be given the option to improve their skills and be better at what they do, while Hugh prefers a more open approach where everyone has the opportunity to excel. They discuss the importance of incentives and the potential drawbacks of a specialized role. The conversation also touches on the idea of personal responsibility and the impact it has on motivation. The use of firearms by police forces varies widely across the world, with some countries having unarmed police forces and others arming their officers. The decision to arm police forces is influenced by factors such as gun use policy, civilian firearm laws, and recording of police activity. Countries with unarmed police forces often have lower gun homicide rates compared to countries with armed police forces. The philosophy of policing by consent is commonly adopted by police forces that do not carry firearms unless the situation warrants it. In a survey conducted in Great Britain, 40% of citizens supported arming all police officers, while 48% were opposed to the idea. Countries with armed police forces tend to have higher gun murder rates compared to countries that don't have armed police. However, this correlation does not imply causation. The conversation explores the use of firearms by police in different countries, focusing on Germany as an example. It discusses the number of shots fired by police in Germany and the resulting fatalities. The conversation also touches on the differences in police training and the potential problems that arise from the use of firearms. The hosts question whether other countries, like Germany, face similar issues with their police forces. The conversation explores the topic of gun violence and police shootings in the United States. The hosts discuss the population size of Germany and America, highlighting the disparity in gun-related deaths between the two countries. They also touch on the issue of police violence and the number of people killed by law enforcement in the US. The conversation raises questions about the need to arm UK police and the problem that needs to be solved in relation to gun violence. The conversation explores the topic of arming police officers and the potential benefits and drawbacks of doing so. The speakers discuss the need for police to have more options to protect themselves and others, but also acknowledge the risks and potential misuse of weapons. They highlight the importance of proper training and testing to ensure that only capable individuals are armed. The conversation concludes with the suggestion that other countries manage without widespread arming of police officers, indicating that it may not be necessary in all situations. The level of training and capability of police officers could be better. While not all police officers are bad, there are always good and bad individuals in any profession. The fitness and standards issue is a separate problem that exacerbates the situation. It is important to recognize that the police are needed for the betterment of society, and those who choose to be in the job should be admired for their dedication. The conversation explores the idea of criticizing institutions from within and the challenges that come with it. It discusses the need for change to come from the top and the responsibility of those in positions of power to enact change. The conversation also touches on the repercussions and personal sacrifices that may come with speaking out against the status quo. The conversation highlights the need for change in organizations and institutions, particularly in leadership positions. The current leadership, often driven by personal gain and career advancement, is not focused on the impact of their actions. The conversation emphasizes the importance of speaking up and standing together to challenge and change the existing system. It also discusses the negative effects of ineffective leadership and the need for a concerted effort to promote suitable leaders. The conversation explores the challenges and issues within civil service and other organizations. It discusses the need for excellence, the impact of politics, and the power of numbers. It emphasizes the importance of standing together and making changes to create a better working environment. The conversation covers various topics related to the challenges and complexities of policing and law enforcement. The hosts discuss the frustrations of civilians who feel powerless to address issues and the need for long-term solutions. They also touch on the role of politics in shaping police forces and the importance of funding and support for law enforcement. The conversation ends with a reflection on the underfunding and understaffing of police departments. The conversation discusses the issue of crime and policing, with a focus on the lack of investigation and the need for improvement. The hosts express frustration with the current system and the ineffectiveness of throwing money at the problem. They highlight the importance of promoting excellence and raising standards in policing. In this conversation, Gaz and Hugh discuss the challenges of their jobs and the desire for a job that provides status and fulfillment. They also touch on the idea that not everyone is interested in joining the military and pursuing elite units, and that many people prefer to stay at home and work on fixing problems in their own communities. The conversation ends with Gaz and Hugh thanking the listeners and encouraging them to support their work.

Chapters00:00

Introduction

03:35

Reputation and Reform: The Use of Firearms by Police

07:42

Handling High-Pressure Conflict Situations

11:04

Recruitment and Effectiveness

14:23

The Limitations of Excessive Force

22:10

The Rise in Violence and Crime Rates

26:11

Rise in Firearms and Knife Offenses

29:39

Rethinking Your Job and Aspiring to Excellence

33:16

Improving Training and Fitness Standards

36:59

Gaz's Perspective: Everyone Should Have a Taser

40:15

The Debate on Employee Incentives

43:48

Variation in the Use of Firearms by Police Forces

47:12

Understanding the Complex Relationship between Armed Police and Gun Violence

50:29

Comparing Police Practices

53:50

Introduction to the topic of arming police officers

57:19

The Importance of Police for the Betterment of Society

01:01:20

The Power of Speaking Up

01:05:07

The Need for Long-Term Solutions

01:06:22

The Importance of Funding and Support

01:06:54

The Challenges of Underfunding and Understaffing

01:08:07

The Lack of Investigation in Reported Crimes

01:08:21

The Ineffectiveness of Throwing Money at Policing

01:09:12

Promoting Excellence and Raising Standards in Policing

01:09:30

The Need for Improvement in the Current System

01:09:37

The Challenges of Jobs and the Desire for Status

01:10:36

Not Everyone Wants to Join the Military

01:11:08

Working on Fixing Problems in Our Communities

01:11:31

Supporting Content Creators and Podcasters

This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sineatersguild.substack.com/subscribe